WASHINGTON (AP) — Republicans accused Planned Parenthood on Tuesday of spending millions of dollars on political activities, travel and lavish salaries, as the GOP tried to build a case for terminating the group's federal money after a series of surreptitiously recorded videos.
Firing back, Cecile Richards, Planned Parenthood's president, said taxpayer money is used to provide sexual disease testing, contraceptives and other health care for women and said none of it is used for political activity. And she said videos released this summer showing Planned Parenthood officials discussing their provision of fetal tissue to medical researchers have prompted increased threats against clinics.
"These acts against women and health care providers don't reflect American values or the rule of law, and I hope this committee will condemn them," she told the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee.
Richards' appearance marked the group's first public face-to-face encounter with Republicans since the videos elevated abortion — and a drive to block Planned Parenthood's federal payments — to a top-tier political issue.
Several Republican presidential hopefuls have condemned Planned Parenthood for its work providing fetal tissue. And conservatives' demands that Congress cut the group's federal payments — for which Republicans lack the votes to succeed — indirectly contributed to the GOP unrest that prompted House Speaker John Boehner, R-Ohio, to announce his resignation last week.
Committee Chairman Jason Chaffetz, R-Utah, said the panel's examination of tax and other documents showed that the group has given $22 million over the past five years to its political affiliate, the Planned Parenthood Action Fund. He said it also spent more than $5 million on "exorbitant" travel in 2013 and paid Richards — who sat at the witness table in front of him — $590,000 in annual salary.
Richards said none of the money Planned Parenthood transfers to its political arm comes from federal taxpayers. The organization receives about a third of its $1.3 billion annual budget, around $450 million, from federal coffers, chiefly reimbursements for treating Medicaid's low-income patients. Virtually no federal dollars can be used for abortions.
Chaffetz said that the group's infusion of federal money lets it use its non-federal dollars for politics.
"That has absolutely nothing to do with young women who need a breast exam," said Chaffetz. "It's a political organization."
In an approaching campaign season in which both parties are competing for female votes, Democrats leapt to Richards' defense.
Citing some GOP lawmakers who interrupted Richards' answers — a common practice in congressional hearings — Rep. Gerald Connolly, D-Va., criticized "the disrespect, the misogyny rampant here today." And Rep. Carolyn Maloney, D-N.Y., accused Chaffetz of "beating up on a woman, to our witness here today, for making a good salary."
Richards said she is "proud" of its provision of fetal tissue for research but also sought to minimize the organ donations as a small part of its work. She also lashed out at her critics for relying on the videos, which were made by David Daleiden and the other anti-abortion activists posing as executives of a phony firm that buys fetal tissue for scientists.
Abortion foes say the videos show the group breaks federal laws barring for-profit fetal tissue sales and altering abortion procedures to obtain usable organs. Planned Parenthood and its defenders say it's done nothing illegal and says that Daleiden dishonestly edited the videos to distort what was said.
"The outrageous accusations leveled against Planned Parenthood, based on heavily doctored videos, are offensive and patently untrue," Richards said.
In her written remarks, Richards said just 1 percent of Planned Parenthood's nearly 700 clinics obtain fetal tissue for researchers seeking disease cures. She said that work is just a "minuscule" part of her organization's services, which include sexual disease testing and the provision of contraception and abortions.
So far, the most damage inflicted on Planned Parenthood by the videos is the insensitive way some of its officials discuss the procedures. That has drawn apologies from Planned Parenthood and bitter criticism from Republicans.
Most Democrats have rallied behind the group, and President Barack Obama has threatened to veto GOP legislation cutting its federal money. Public opinion polls show majorities oppose blocking Planned Parenthood's taxpayer dollars. Boehner and Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., fearing voter anger, have rebuffed conservatives who would shut down the government if Obama doesn't agree to halt Planned Parenthood's money.
Democrats have used a Senate filibuster — a virtually endless procedural delay — to block GOP legislation halting Planned Parenthood's federal payments. So two House committees plan to approve filibuster-proof legislation shifting Planned Parenthood's Medicaid funds — about $350 million — to community health centers.
The bill also would keep a promise made during this spring's budget debate to repeal key elements of Obama's signature health care law.
Planned Parenthood has defended itself with newspaper ads, petition campaigns and lawsuits against state efforts to curb its funding. On Tuesday, volunteers and supporters scheduled events in nearly 90 cities and planned to give lawmakers more than 2 million signatures on "I Stand With Planned Parenthood" petitions.
___
Associated Press writer David Crary contributed to this report.
I think Planned Parenthood is an important resource for young women. Although some things they do there is cruel depending on who you ask, it's important for it to be an option for people. "Abortion foes say the videos show the group breaks federal laws barring for-profit fetal tissue sales and altering abortion procedures to obtain usable organs. Planned Parenthood and its defenders say it's done nothing illegal and says that Daleiden dishonestly edited the videos to distort what was said.". Abortion is not illegal and they need funds to continue helping people.
ReplyDeleteI believe Planned Parenthood is very important to have in our country although some of the stuff they purchase may be unnecessary for example “Planned Parenthood on Tuesday of spending millions of dollars on political activities, travel and lavish salaries, as the GOP tried to build a case for terminating the group's federal money after a series of surreptitiously recorded videos” (WASHINGTON (AP). I think it is good that what is happening here is not affected towards American Values, because it is the company who is doing this not all the people. All in all I think Planned Parenthood understood what they have done is not all that effective and they are now making changes.
ReplyDelete-Megan Welter Per. 2
Planned Parenthood is a very important aspect to young woman. Of course some actions they are making aren't the best. "And she said videos released this summer showing Planned Parenthood officials discussing their provision of fetal tissue to medical researchers have prompted increased threats against clinics". But Planned Parenthood had realized the mistakes they made and did apologize "So far, the most damage inflicted on Planned Parenthood by the videos is the insensitive way some of its officials discuss the procedures. That has drawn apologies from Planned Parenthood and bitter criticism from Republicans". After what Planned Parenthood went through its good to see they still have volunteers and supporters.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you Amy, I believe that Planet Parenthood is very important to young woman but they could have made some better choices recently. They have apologized for there mistakes as well. "Firing back, Cecile Richards, Planned Parenthood's president, said taxpayer money is used to provide sexual disease testing, contraceptives and other health care for women and said none of it is used for political activity." There money has been used for testing and healthcare problems.
DeleteI don't think Planned Parenthood should be stopped. It is very important for wrong women. But I also believe they have made bad choices recently. I do not abortions should be altered to be able to study fetus tissues. But Planned Parenthood also apologized for this. They also explained how none of the tax payers money is being used for campaigns. I believe Planned Parenthood is very important and should not be stopped.
ReplyDeletePlanned Parenthood needs to be able not only to provide safe abortions, but for other reasons such as STD screenings and providing contraceptives (as mentioned in the article). The Republicans that are trying to stop federal funding for PP make it seem that the taxpayers are paying for the abortions and not so much other health issues. Planned Parenthood should still be able to use the aborted fetuses for research. With the fetuses, whether or not they altered the methods of obtaining them, are still valuable for finding cures to diseases.
ReplyDeleteWe need to have planned parenthood in out community. I feel like some of the stuff they purchase is unnecessary. When the "officials discuss their provision of fetal tissue to medical researchers" You can tell that they are really trying to make this a useful tool for teens. Even though planned parent hood has some down sides I do not think it should be stopped.
ReplyDeleteI completly dissagree with stoping funding for planed parrenthood. I think that it is important for young woman who are nit ready to be parents. It dosnt only benfit the woman but it also helps from rasing a child in an unsafe enviorment. Planned parrent hood also helps victums of rape so they are not forced to have a baby they do ot want. So I belive that the goverment should keep funding planned parrenthood for those reasons.
ReplyDeletePlanned parent hood needs to continue going in our community. This is such a useful source to so many, we can greatly benefit from Planned Parenthood. Of course they have made some mistakes, but overall it is a great resource for many.
ReplyDeletePlanned Parenthood has been helpful to many women in our community. I think it is a wise investment for California to have. If they are spending their money on testing STD's and contraceptives for women, I don't think it is a "waste of money" considering the effects that come after the disease isn't cured or contraceptives aren't available, are far worse than spending money to prevent it. Many businesses have downfalls to them but the amount of advantages that planned parenthood has makes it worth it.
ReplyDeletePlanned Parenthood is an essential part of our country. It aides women and families in providing health care. If Planned Parenthood was no longer funded there would be a decrease in the overall health of women and their families because there would be an increased chance of breast cancer with the lack of mammogram screenings along with the higher increase of sti's and std's coming from the lack of health care provided to help sexual health. -Sabrina Shaw Per. 4
ReplyDeleteWe need Planned Parenthood in our community. It benefits the mother and it helps raise a child. It is important for us to have Planned Parenthood. "Firing back, Cecile Richards, Planned Parenthood's president, said taxpayer money is used to provide sexual disease testing, contraceptives and other health care for women and said none of it is used for political activity." She is right because this helps provide for sexual disease testing and other health care for women. We need Planned Parenthood to help keep the mother and child in good health conditions, and keep anything bad from happening.
ReplyDeletePlanned Parenthood is an import thing. The government should still fund them because taxpayers money goes to a good cause. "Planned Parenthood's president, said taxpayer money is used to provide sexual disease testing, contraceptives and other health care for women and said none of it is used for political activity Planned Parenthood Spends Federal Money On Politics (Associated Press))." Planned Parenthood seeks help for women that they may not be fortunate enough to get somewhere else. Keep funding Planned Parenthood.
ReplyDeleteKyle Brown P.5
Planned Parenthood is really important for us to have. Not everyone is ready to be a parent and people need to understand that. I don't necessarily agree with all of the decisions they make, but they also do good. Planned parenthood has helped a lot of young women and it continues to do so.
ReplyDeletePlanned Parenthood is an important asset to society now a days. People make mistakes and bringing an infant into this world unexpectedly or unknowingly can probably be very scary and nerve racking. Resources like Planned Parenthood is a great place for women to go for the stability and support they cannot get elsewhere. I believe California should keep this up because they are actually doing good for the community.
ReplyDeleteCarissa
Planned Parenthood is a very helpful place for women to turn to. It provides knowledge, "...sexual disease testing, contraceptives, and other health care..." for women everywhere (Washington AP). They may have made a few mistakes recently, but all-in-all, Planned Parenthood should continue to be funded, because it helps thousands of women with their health and helps them prevent bad-situations for themselves.
ReplyDeleteI believe Planned Parenthood is a very helpful thing in a community. Not only is it very important to provide a safe environment for different tests, but it also is something I think is necessary to have. Yes, they could've done things better, but I don't think that means it should be shut down. Funding for Planned Parenthood should continue, it is a really good resource for many.
ReplyDeletePlanned parent hood is a very good resource. This is something that women need not to rely on, but to only use after a mistake. Mistakes happen and there needs to be ways to fix a mistake. Planned Parent hood needs to keep fundraising and expand on research.
ReplyDeletePlanned parent hood is not something the government should be spending money on. If somebody would want birth control it is very affordable. If we spend money on this we are basically just spending money on testing babies when they are fetuses which is very sickening.
ReplyDeletePlanned Parenthood is a useful source for young women. It provides knowledge in a safe environment. It is a woman's right to have options for herself if she is not ready to bare a child. Panned Parenthood provides easy access to sexual disease testing and abortions and the government should not stop funding the project.
ReplyDeleteAlexis Miller period 6
Planned Parenthood should continue to grow and develop research making improvements on their system. It is an important for women to keep all of their options open. "Cecile Richards, Planned Parenthood's president, said taxpayer money is used to provide sexual disease testing, contraceptives and other health care for women and said none of it is used for political activity." Planned Parenthood is developing a safe working environment and procedure to ensure full care of the women and the child. Planned parenthood is a huge help for women.
ReplyDeleteI think planned parenthood is a important program for young women. It provides not only information but health care. It is a place for girls to go if they need help. A safe environment is not abaliable to women. I belive that planned parenthood should continue to be funded to give girls resources if they need it.
ReplyDeletePlanned parenthood should be continued for a good reason. I think women should be able to have this resource as something not to always rely on, but have if they need it. Some people beleieve that this shouldnt be avaiable for people, but i feel it should. Even though these people might not of made the best decisions, planned parenthood is there for them. This is something that i feel should be there when people need it
ReplyDelete